Photograph: Alaa Alqaisi
I write in the shadow of another Modest Proposal. Jonathan Swift, confronting the brutal conditions in Ireland under English rule, once adopted the measured, rational voice of policy in order to expose the violence concealed within it. What Swift grasped with devastating clarity was that power does not always shout; it often speaks in the calm language of order, necessity, and public good, and in doing so renders its own cruelty intelligible, even acceptable. Centuries later, Refaat Alareer returned to that same form and, in 2010, turned it towards Gaza—already wounded, already blockaded, already subjected to destruction articulated as procedure. I write now after him, and in the wake of what has followed, from a Gaza far more devastated than the one he addressed: a place not merely besieged but systematically dismantled; not merely starved but stripped, in full view of the world, of the conditions that make life recognisable as life.
It has by now been more than sufficiently established, through figures repeated until they lose all power to disturb those who were determined not to be disturbed, that the Gaza Strip, whose total area does not exceed 365 square kilometres, has been reduced to a condition approaching total ruin. Ninety percent of it is destroyed. More than two hundred and thirty thousand tons of explosives have been dropped upon that narrow strip of land, a quantity so monstrous that language recoils from it, though the earth of Gaza has had no such luxury. The officially recorded dead now number 74,480 souls, while an estimated 9,500 remain missing, buried perhaps beneath stone, cement, twisted steel, and the indifference that settles so quickly over the crushed body of an Arab child. The injured number 175,539, though one must admit that injury in this case is too weak a word, since it is used alike for the loss of a hand, the loss of an eye, the loss of a face, the loss of a mother, the loss of all one had ever known of ordinary life.
There are more than 2,700 families erased in full, removed from the civil register as if they had never loved, never argued over bread, never folded children’s clothes, never waited at dusk for one son to come home later than he promised. More than twelve thousand miscarriages have been recorded because hunger, terror, displacement, and the collapse of medical care have made even the womb an unsafe place. At least 466 people have died of hunger and malnutrition, though hunger has always been a discreet executioner, less spectacular than a missile and therefore more acceptable to a watching world. It proceeds without flame, without the immediate vulgarity of shrapnel, and thus suits the conscience of governments that prefer death to come slowly, administratively, and with sufficient deniability. Nor does death necessarily release the body from administration. Israel has withheld the remains of Palestinians, leaving families to petition for the elementary right to bury their dead.
As for the living, they persist, if persistence is the word for sleeping under torn fabric, queuing for hours in hope of flour, drinking grief with brackish water, and measuring one’s day by the search for bread, wood, medicine, clean cloth, or a corner in which one may weep unseen. Life has been reduced to the dimensions of a tent, and even the word ‘tent’ flatters what is often no more than a thin argument against wind, rain, cold, heat, insects, surveillance, memory, and despair. A tent is now expected to perform the offices once assigned to house, school, clinic, kitchen, neighbourhood, and nation. It is to shelter the newly orphaned, the amputated, the feverish, the widowed, the half-mad, the newly born, and those who would prefer not to have survived at all, had survival meant this.
And here one must speak of the psychological matter, since statistics, while useful for diplomacy and newspaper layouts, have proven insufficient to convey what has become of the people who remain. After three years of massacre, siege, hunger, and exposure, the people of Gaza have been disfigured twice: once in body, and once in soul. There are the plainly visible mutilations—burned skin, severed limbs, collapsed spines, faces unmade and reconstructed only partly by exhausted surgeons working without anaesthetic, electricity, or adequate medical supplies. And there are other mutilations which do not bleed so openly and are therefore easier for the civilised world to ignore. A people has been drained of the ordinary sequence by which life becomes livable. Morning no longer promises a day; night no longer promises rest. The familiar objects of existence—home, school, market, tree, window, street, kettle, blanket, photograph—have either vanished or become instruments of mourning. Many have been emptied out of themselves and of everything they once found natural in the world. It is as if the Genocide has not only struck them from outside but hollowed them from within, until they move through the day carrying the shape of human beings and the exhaustion of ghosts.
Children wake screaming from dreams they are too young to name. Mothers speak in the present tense to sons buried months ago. Fathers sit before tents with the stunned stillness of men who have failed to protect what no man could have protected. Young people, who ought to be impatient for the future, now speak with the dry resignation of the elderly, as though time itself has withdrawn its promise from them. Those who live are not simply survivors. They are witnesses trapped inside the scene of their witnessing. They have seen too much and too often, and the repetition of catastrophe has left many unable to imagine a life not organised around alertness, dread, deprivation, and sudden loss. They are not merely hungry. They are estranged from appetite itself. They are not merely displaced. They are severed from the very idea that a place might hold them gently.
Now, in the light of these considerations, there must surely be a practical way forward. I shall therefore humbly propose my own thoughts, which I hope will not be liable to the least objection from those statesmen, commentators, military analysts, and institutional mourners who have accepted every degree of destruction short of naming the intention behind it. Since Gaza has already been made uninhabitable, and since its people continue, scandalously, to insist on existing amid ruin, I suggest that the international community, together with the powers that finance, arm, excuse, and philosophise over this slaughter, dispense at last with the tiring rituals of pretended concern. Let them cease speaking of collateral damage, humanitarian pauses, tragic complexity, and regrettable civilian tolls. Let them say simply and efficiently that the problem with Gaza is that Gazans are still in it.
This would save a great deal of time. It would relieve officials of the strain of performing sorrow they do not feel. It would reduce the burden on journalists obliged to balance a child without a head against a spokesman with a necktie. It would spare diplomats the trouble of issuing urgent statements composed entirely of passive verbs. It would free the architects of this devastation from the inconvenience of disguising exterminatory desire beneath legal formulas and strategic vocabulary. For if one has destroyed homes, bakeries, schools, universities, hospitals, refugee camps, water networks, roads, archives, mosques, churches, olive groves, police stations, municipal buildings, cultural centres, and entire bloodlines, then surely it is tedious to go on pretending that one’s grievance is with a faction rather than with the people among whom that faction was said to live.
I therefore propose that, instead of continuing this expensive and repetitive method by which Gazans are starved slowly, bombed periodically, displaced endlessly, and then studied as a humanitarian concern, the matter be brought to its logical conclusion. The surviving population should be regarded as excess to requirement: a troublesome remainder, a persistent residue of life interfering with the smooth completion of an already well-advanced project. Those who have not been killed outright may be left to hunger with greater efficiency, denied medicine with greater discipline, and herded from one zone of supposed safety to another until movement itself becomes a form of death. This policy, I think, would have several clear advantages.
First, it would satisfy the appetite for consistency. The present arrangement suffers from a contradiction too obvious to ignore: the destruction is nearly total, but the language remains timid. Whole neighbourhoods are erased, and yet every announcement insists on restraint. Children are pulled out in pieces, and yet every panel discussion returns obediently to ‘context.’ By completing openly what has been pursued materially for months and years, the authors of this age could bring language into proper alignment with action.
Second, it would be economical. There would be no need to rebuild what may be destroyed again, no need to permit aid only to obstruct it, no need to produce the theatre of negotiation around how much starvation may be allowed before it becomes embarrassing. The destruction of Gaza’s universities may be recorded as damage to infrastructure, the killing of Refaat Alareer, who taught in one of them, as another civilian death. By this admirable division of accounts, the destruction of an intellectual world can be acknowledged without ever having to reckon with what has been lost. The current method requires a considerable investment in weapons, propaganda, and moral cosmetics. A more candid arrangement would spare all that.
Third, and perhaps most mercifully according to the ethics of empire, it would solve the psychological problem of the survivors. For what exactly is being preserved when a people is forced to remain alive after being stripped of shelter, continuity, dignity, and the smallest expectation of safety? Is this the celebrated gift of survival? To sleep beneath plastic sheets and be expected to regard the arrangement as protection? To discover that every place designated safe may be made dangerous by the authority that designated it? To carry in one body the exhaustion of hunger, bereavement, humiliation, untreated illness, and unending vigilance? To be told that the restoration of normal life must begin with the recovery of one’s mental health, while the circumstances that have destroyed it are permitted to continue? If the world has already decided that Gazans may be broken in every possible way, then why hesitate at brokenness complete enough to satisfy the logic already in motion?
Fourth, it would honour the moral clarity of those who have told us, year after year, that there is no partner for peace, no innocent civilian in a militant landscape, no way to distinguish child from threat, tent from target, school from barracks, hospital from military headquarters. Such convictions deserve the courage of their own completion. Let those who have treated every Gazan body as provisionally killable admit, with admirable frankness, that the proposal has never been to manage danger, but to erase the people onto whom danger may always be projected.
I can think of no serious objection that would not also condemn the present reality, unless one wishes to maintain that it is somehow more humane to kill a people gradually rather than outright, more lawful to starve them than to shoot them, more civilised to leave them in tents than to confess that one has destroyed the meaning of home itself. If any person of conscience should protest that this proposal is monstrous, I would answer that monstrosity is already the governing fact. My contribution is only to strip away the language that conceals it.
I write, then, in the tradition of Swift and in the shadow of Refaat Alareer, though with this bitter disadvantage: where they used satire to unmask barbarity, I write at a moment when barbarity has grown so immense that satire can scarcely enlarge it. Swift wrote from Ireland to reveal the appetite of colonial power. Refaat wrote from Gaza in 2010 to show that the old appetite had found a new vocabulary. I write now because the proposal they both exposed has been carried forward almost to completion. The poor in Ireland were treated as burdens. Gazans were treated as targets. Now they are treated as aftermath while they still breathe.
And so I submit, with all due modesty, that if the world insists on allowing Gaza to remain a place where every form of life is attacked, its homes demolished, its children maimed, its mothers starved, its fathers humiliated, its unborn expelled from the womb, its dead left under rubble, its living made to envy them, then it should at least abandon the vanity of pretending that this is war in any meaningful sense. It is the methodical erasure of a people, disguised as the management of their survival.
A modest proposal, indeed.